Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Reading the Upcoming Holiday Season: Retailers Should Be Careful With Aggressive Discounts

Frank Badillo, vice president and senior retail economist at Kantar Retail specializes in analysis and forecasting of economic, retail and consumer trends. He contributes to Kantar’s retail intelligence platform and regularly writes about the economic outlook for the monthly Retail Economist newsletter. He also directs the retail channel and product category forecasts for the annual US Retail Outlook. I chatted with Badillo about the upcoming holiday season and the state of the retail sector.
eMarketer: What is your outlook for the upcoming online holiday shopping season?
Badillo:
What we see that non-store sales and online shopping in particular have been very strong for the last six months. It’s been the strongest channel among of all of retailing. The channel is benefiting, to some extent, from a very weak year-ago comparison period, but it’s pretty clear that there’s strong demand for goods online. Right now through September is going to be key. There’s the back-to-school spurt, but we don’t really know what it portends for the holiday exactly.
A lot of demand we see tends to be skewed toward electronics. There are a lot of hot gadgets out there between the iPad, e-book readers and smartphones. All those things are driving very strong demand. Particularly with the e book readers, there’s a lot of demand among early adopters. The big question is to what extent a lot of that growth can be sustained in the longer term.
I suspect that we’re going to see very healthy growth into the holiday. It just may moderate somewhat from the very strong growth we’ve seen in recent months.
eMarketer: So consumer electronics in particular will have a strong holiday season.
Badillo:
Exactly, and particularly online.
eMarketer: Do you think online shopping behavior will be different this year?
Badillo:
In our monthly Shopperscape surveys, we ask a question about consumers’ spending intentions. The response has been steadily improving over the past year. There was a bit of a blip in our June number, but generally there’s been improvement in spending intentions over time. We expect that to continue and result in much better spending into the holiday than we saw last year.
But at the same time, there is some renewed uncertainty among shoppers that could curb some of the spending improvement in the coming months. I suspect that by the holiday time frame, some of that uncertainty should be cleared up and we’ll see the recovery continue, albeit at a bit more modest pace than we saw in the initial months of the year.
eMarketer: What key challenges will retailers face this holiday season?
Badillo:
Retailers cut prices pretty dramatically last year to draw shoppers and, in the end, it probably did more to weaken their top line sales as well as their profits. They will want to try to avoid the kind of ruinous price competition that they engaged in last year and try to be more strategic about it for this holiday.
Retailers are struggling with the extent to which they need to boost their inventories amid signs of rebounding demand. We’ve gone through a phase where retailers dramatically cut back their inventories. So now they’re slowly increasing those inventories again. The question is, to what extent they should continue to do that? There’s just a lot of uncertainty about whether they should do that.
I suspect we’ll see inventories expand a bit too much, which is going to put some downward pressure on prices for the second half of the year. We’ve already seen some signs of that in the apparel sector. There’s some growing price pressure in the sector after a good year or so of very slight price increases.
The inventory question is huge for a lot of retailers heading into the holidays, as well as the related pricing question. If there’s inventory overhang through the holiday, that’s going to put downward pressure on prices.
But there’s also the question as to when retailers should roll out promotions. Given how much price competition there was last year, I think retailers are going to look all the more closely about what they price-promote and the timing of those price promotions.
eMarketer: What are your projections for overall retail growth?
Badillo:
For total retail sales, excluding autos and gasoline, we’re looking for overall growth in the second half of the year of about 3.5%. The government numbers out today [July 14] show that we’ve had growth averaging about 3.9% for the last two months.
In terms of the government numbers, non-store sales are growing at a double-digit pace. Online probably represents the lion’s share of non-store sales. It’s also going to include catalog sales but I suspect that it’s the online shopping that’s driving the double-digit growth. We’ll continue to see double-digit growth in online sales through the holiday which can only mean that the average market basket size for any given shopper will grow significantly compared to a year ago.
The full version of this interview is available here, to eMarketer Total Access clients only. Every day they have access to new interviews with digital marketing leaders and trendsetting entrepreneurs.
Click here to learn more about how becoming an eMarketer Total Access client can strengthen your business.






