Thursday, April 29, 2010
Mobile Market Realigns Again with HP Acquisition of Palm
The tweets were predictable: “Somebody just dropped an H-Palm,” “HP saves Palm,” my own “New lease on life for WebOS,” and some contrarian views, including noted tech blogger Om Malik’s assertion that “hp buying palm makes no sense to me.” Yes, the news about Hewlett-Packard’s $1.2 billion acquisition of struggling smartphone manufacturer Palm (official transcript from HP conference call available here) temporarily gave mobile industry watchers something to tweet about other than Apple (which made smaller waves of its own yesterday and signaled its intent to take on Google in mobile search by buying mobile assistant app maker Siri).
The HP acquisition is certainly a game-changer for Palm, saving the company from the looming prospect of oblivion, but it’s not yet clear whether it represents a dramatic realignment for the industry. As Forrester Research’s Ian Fogg and Current Analysis’ Avi Greengart pointed out yesterday, the combined HP/Palm is a stronger entity, but faces the same competitors as before, in the same increasingly heated battle over the growing overlap between computing devices and mobile devices.
This is a battle in which Apple arguably retains a significant lead. In a well-argued post, Creative Strategies president Tim Bajarin succinctly described Apple’s advantage as follows:
Apple did not just come out with a new smart phone. They delivered a complete solution that included hardware, software, and services. More importantly, they controlled the complete customer experience. This is very much at the heart of why Apple is so successful with the iPhone.
Yes, HP now has hardware and software expertise under one roof, and yes, there are personnel synergies (Palm alumni in HP’s Personal Systems Group), but hardware and software are still just two sides of the mobile triangle. The missing piece is content, and that’s a key part of what generates Apple’s appeal. On the HP conference call, JPMorgan analyst Rod Hall asked Todd Bradley, the EVP of HP’s Personal Systems Group, to talk about HP/Palm’s content strategy, and Mr. Bradley responded as follows:
Our focus is to provide connected devices that enable people to safely and seamlessly connect to that information that is important to them, be that entertainment or work or personal data. So I don’t think we are content creators, but we are access providers.
Better distribution and stronger marketing support will certainly help Palm’s prospects, but they only get you so far these days. As InformationWeek’s Eric Zeman put it:
HP’s buy-out of Palm does not improve the developer story at all. Without developers who are committed to writing apps, webOS can’t have a future — or at least can’t have a future that is as full and rich as its competitors.
Therein lies the challenge. Now the industry will wait to see how successfully HP/Palm can meet it.








